The transition of flamenco into the commercial space of the cafés cantantes during the late nineteenth century is frequently narrated as a straightforward moment of professionalisation and economic expansion. Yet, this prevailing historiography routinely ignores the violent epistemological and material processes of racialisation that underpinned this shift. This period must be understood, in other words, not merely as a commercial boom, but as the precise historical moment when the gitano body was systematically inscribed within a rigid, racialised taxonomy. The Andalusian Roma, historically subjected to draconian assimilationist decrees, were suddenly thrust onto the stages of urban centres, refigured as the primitive, exotic ‘other’ against which a modernising, bourgeois Spanish identity could define itself (in line with global-north-thinking).

This process of racialisation relied heavily on the emerging pseudosciences of the era and an entrenchment of the broader European colonial imagination. The gitano was constructed, to put it perhaps a little too starkly, as an internal ‘oriental’ other. On the stage of the café cantante, the gitano performer was not perceived as an artist engaging in complex syncretic practices, but rather as an atavistic vessel of raw, unmediated passion. This perception was the result of a process of ontological flattening: the ethnocentric framework that demanded that the gitano perform a hyper-racialised version of themselves, was also one that satisfied the bourgeois appetite for danger, primitivism, and an imagined (constructed, nostalgic) pre-industrial melancholy.
The racialisation of flamenco during this period must be understood as part of a wider project of biopolitical control. By isolating the gitano as a racial category defined by inherent musicality and uncontrollable bodily excess, the Spanish establishment effectively contained the threat of Roma integration and political solidarity. K. Meira Goldberg’s vital work on the ‘blackness’ of flamenco highlights how these racialised discourses mapped directly onto the performing body. The intricate footwork, the contorted postures, and the guttural vocality of cante jondo were interpreted by late nineteenth-century commentators as physiological evidence of racial difference. It took the highly cultivated and sophisticated flamenco practices and reduced them to a primitive ‘natural wellspring,’ erasing the intense labour and pedagogy required to master the form.
Crucially, Spanish scholars who have rigorously dismantled these essentialist myths, refusing the romanticised paradigms that dominated early flamencology such as José Luis Ortiz Nuevo, have been instrumental in deconstructing the racialised fiction of an isolated, purely gitano flamenco. Through his exhaustive examination of the nineteenth-century Sevillian press, Ortiz Nuevo demonstrates that the cafés cantantes were sites of profound transcultural exchange, rather than hermetically sealed racial showcases, as many contemporaneous commentators sought to represent them. The early commercialisation of the art form relied on a diverse, working-class Andalusian coalition. The subsequent ideological drive to retroactively assign ownership of specific styles to exclusive racial categories was a deliberate historical distortion.
Building upon this archival foundation, Antonio Manuel has systematically deconstructed the invention of flamenco ‘purity’ or pureza. His archaeological approach to flamenco history exposes how the racialised ‘Gitano‘ category was weaponised to obscure the profound Moorish, Morisco, and Black African roots of Andalusian expressive culture. Furthermore, the anthropological interventions of Cristina Cruces Roldán highlight how the folkloric reduction of flamenco served state and bourgeois interests. Indeed, Cruces Roldán demonstrates that the ethnocentric gaze of the late nineteenth century effectively separated the Gitano from the broader socio-economic realities of Andalusia, repackaging their cultural expression as an innate, racially determined artefact.
The folkloric interventions of the 1880s, most notably in the work of Antonio Machado y Álvarez (Demófilo), present a related historiographical problem. While often credited with preserving the lyrical corpus of early flamenco, his taxonomical approach was deeply embedded in the racial logic of his time. By rigidly categorising songs as either gitano or Andaluz, early folklorists imposed a binary racial framework upon a fluid, working-class cultural commons. This ethnocentric desire to catalogue and contain the authentic gitano voice effectively stripped the music of its dynamic social context, freezing it as a racial artefact for scholarly and bourgeois consumption.
It is in this exact period, the so-called Edad de oro or Golden Age, that the pernicious discourse of purity begins to take deep root. Often mistaken for a benign aesthetic standard, the late nineteenth-century invention of flamenco purity was a deeply racialised construct. It served to delineate the boundaries of legitimate performance, inextricably linking authenticity to bloodlines. This romanticisation of blood purity masked the brutal material realities of agrarian capitalism in Andalusia. By framing flamenco as a racially hermetic practice, commentators erased the long history of cross-cultural exchange between Gitanos, Moriscos, enslaved Black populations, and working-class Andalusians. The discourse of race was thus deployed to obscure class solidarity and material deprivation, transforming systemic poverty into a commodified aesthetic spectacle.
To study the media archaeology and cultural history of early flamenco is to confront this legacy of racialisation directly. The archival traces of the late nineteenth century, including photographs, promotional posters, and early textual accounts, do not merely document an evolving art form. They are the material residue of a racialising gaze. These documents reveal how the Gitano body was commodified, packaged, and sold to a public hungry for ‘authentic’ primitivism. When analysing the visual culture of the cafés cantantes, for example, the deliberate staging of race becomes evident, where performers were frequently required to dress in ways that exaggerated their ethnic identity, conforming to the stereotypes established by earlier romantic literature and travelogues. Deconstructing these ethnocentric frameworks requires rejecting the romanticised mythologies of the late nineteenth century and instead analysing flamenco as a dynamic, syncretic practice that survived despite the crushing weight of racialised commodification.
Bibliography
Cruces Roldán, Cristina, El flamenco como patrimonio: una aproximación antropológica (Sevilla: Centro de Estudios Andaluces, 2003).
Goldberg, K. Meira, Sonidos Negros: On the Blackness of Flamenco (New York: Oxford University Press, 2019).
Manuel, Antonio, Flamenco: Arqueología de lo jondo (Córdoba: Almuzara, 2018).
Ortiz Nuevo, José Luis, ¿Se sabe algo? Viaje al conocimiento del arte flamenco en la prensa sevillana del siglo XIX (Sevilla: Ediciones El Carro de la Nieve, 1990).


Leave a Reply